Why Nigeria’s Financial Sector Needs Feminist Reforms

Photo illustration by Dami Mojid / THE REPUBLIC. (L-R) FCMB‘s Yemisi Edun, Molara Ogundipe-Leslie, Citi Bank’s Ireti Samuel-Ogbu & Fidelity Bank’s Nneka Onyeali-Ikpe.

THE MINISTRY OF BUSINESS X THE ECONOMY

Why Nigeria’s Financial Sector Needs Feminist Reforms

Despite visible strides in gender diversity within Nigeria’s financial sector, deep-rooted systemic inequalities persist, undermining genuine progress. Addressing these challenges requires moving beyond surface-level metrics to implement transformative policies that foster true inclusivity and equity.

Photo illustration by Dami Mojid / THE REPUBLIC. (L-R) FCMB‘s Yemisi Edun, Molara Ogundipe-Leslie, Citi Bank’s Ireti Samuel-Ogbu & Fidelity Bank’s Nneka Onyeali-Ikpe.

THE MINISTRY OF BUSINESS X THE ECONOMY

Why Nigeria’s Financial Sector Needs Feminist Reforms

Despite visible strides in gender diversity within Nigeria’s financial sector, deep-rooted systemic inequalities persist, undermining genuine progress. Addressing these challenges requires moving beyond surface-level metrics to implement transformative policies that foster true inclusivity and equity.

Nigeria’s financial services sector is undergoing a notable transformation, with more women rising to executive roles and board positions. For example, in the deposit money banking sub-sector, female representation on boards has increased from 19 per cent in 2013 to 29.4 per cent in 2022. These advancements appear to signal progress toward gender equity and toward challenging long-standing societal norms in a traditionally male-dominated industry. In 2012, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) gave a directive under Principle 4 of the Nigerian Sustainable Banking Principles that mandated financial institutions to publish gender-related data across their business units. This was supposed to be an indication of a commitment to diversity. It is important to note that the United Nations Development Programme defines equal representation as falling within a range of 45 per cent to 54 per cent female participation. However, despite these frameworks and guidelines, much of the progress remains surface level. Women may be stepping more into executive roles, but this often masks the deeply rooted systemic challenges that persist beneath the surface. Institutionalized biases and structural barriers continue to limit genuine inclusion and equity, just as diversity quotas and policies, although important, have become performative measures rather than transformative tools.

Nigerian feminist, Molara Ogundipe-Leslie’s concept of Stiwanism offers a powerful lens to understand how the financial services sector in Nigeria—and by extension, across Africa—perpetuates systemic barriers for women under the guise of empowerment. Stiwanism, which stands for ‘Social Transformation Including Women in Africa’, speaks directly to how dynamics like age, marital status and culture, are often weaponized by institutions to marginalize women while projecting an image of progressiveness. By framing these issues through Stiwanism, we can better understand how this exclusion is not merely an issue within Nigeria’s financial sector, but a reflection of what Ogundipe-Leslie termed the ‘six mountains’ that African women must overcome. These mountains include colonialism, neo-colonialism, patriarchy, tradition, poverty and illiteracy—all of which intersect and compound the challenges faced by women.  

Practices within Nigeria’s financial services sector reveal how these mountains manifest in contemporary settings. Ageism, cultural bias and marital discrimination, among other challenges, function as modern-day extensions of traditional barriers, repackaged to fit within a neoliberal framework. These challenges and disparities urgently call for the application of feminist theory that highlights the persistent structural and systemic inequalities women experience in the society and workplace. Post-feminist perspectives suggest that the mere presence of women in leadership roles is evidence of equality achieved. Feminist theory, however, counters that entrenched patriarchal norms and institutional barriers continue to limit women’s opportunities and perpetuate gender disparities. We cannot ignore how corporate cultures in Nigeria align themselves with global neoliberal trends that disproportionately harm African women, extracting their labour while denying them true power. The post-feminist alliance with neoliberal practices has led to insidious strategies like purple-washing, where banks appropriate feminist language while maintaining oppressive systems. These initiatives create illusions of progress while cementing the status quo, leaving women perpetually underrepresented and undervalued despite their presence in annual reports and publicity photos. 

WORKFORCE DIVERSITY TRENDS

To understand recent trends in diversity within the financial services sector, I conducted a content analysis of annual financial statements from 41 publicly listed companies, from 2018 to 2022. The numbers tell a deceptively hopeful story: total workforce diversity appeared to improve, with female representation climbing from 40.76 per cent in 2018 to 47.30 per cent in 2022. At first glance, these statistics paint a picture of progress and suggest gender parity may have finally arrived in Nigeria’s financial sector as female representation crosses the critical 45 per cent threshold. Yet, behind these figures lies a troubling reality that my research has uncovered. Drawing from my ongoing study on gender equality in Nigeria’s financial sector—research I conducted across both Nigeria and Sweden with support from the Nordic Africa Institute—I found that this apparent 16 per cent increase in female representation masks significant gaps in transparency and accountability. My content analysis revealed that in 2018, a mere 26 firms bothered to report gender-specific information in their annual reports. By 2022, the situation had not improved—three firms (International Energy Insurance Plc., Niger Insurance Plc., and Standard Alliance Insurance Plc.) failed to submit annual returns, while only 22 of the remaining 38 published reports included any quantitative data on workforce gender diversity.  

This persistent data gap is not merely an administrative oversight. It fundamentally undermines our ability to accurately monitor and evaluate genuine progress toward gender equality. We also see tangible evidence of how ‘purple-washing’ permeates these corporate documents. This practice, where companies position themselves as champions of women’s rights while implementing no meaningful changes, has become deeply embedded in this sector. Companies proudly proclaim their commitment to gender equality through glossy reports and carefully worded mission statements, while their actual policies and practices continue to reinforce the very disparities they claim to address. For example, Jaiz Bank Nigeria Plc. had no female representation on its board from 2013 to 2020, a significant deviation from the CBN’s 30 per cent quota. Additionally, as of 2022, the proportion of women in its workforce stood at just 26 per cent—well below the sector average of 47.30 per cent. Despite these shortcomings, the bank’s annual report states: 

The Bank is committed to establishing itself as a pioneer among member organizations in diversity and inclusion. This entails creating a welcoming workplace where each employee can realize their full potential, while attracting, nurturing, and retaining a diverse talent pool. 

This discrepancy between stated commitments and actual performance highlights a gap between policy rhetoric and practice that underscores the need for more meaningful action to foster genuine gender inclusion. 

shop the republic

shop the republic

From the above-mentioned analysis of annual reports in my work, the average number of women on boards has steadily increased each year. Between 2018 and 2022, this figure rose from 1.27 to 2.34, representing an 84 per cent increase. The proportion of women on boards has also grown, moving from an average of 17.35 per cent in 2018 to 23.89 per cent in 2022—an improvement of 38 per cent over five years. However, women’s participation in audit committees, often viewed as a more technical role, increased more modestly from 16.17 per cent to 20.44 per cent, a 26 per cent rise. This slower pace suggests that while board-level representation has improved significantly, progress in technical leadership roles lags. 

Although the average number of women on boards increased dramatically (84 per cent), the smaller proportional increase (38 per cent) suggests that male executive numbers have also grown. The current average of 23 per cent female board representation most notably remains below the CBN’s recommended quota of 30 per cent. 

Beneath the promising façade of progress in gender diversity lies a deeper set of challenges that continue to undermine womens contributions and wellbeing. While women have achieved visible successes at the top, many still face systemic issues, including exploitative employment practices, cultural biases and regulatory gaps. These hidden challenges highlight entrenched gender disparities that must be addressed to unlock the full potential of female talent in the sector. 

The CBN currently holds the world’s highest cash reserve ratio at 45 per cent, requiring financial institutions to maintain 45 per cent of their customer deposits with the apex bank. This policy drives aggressive deposit mobilization targets, which disproportionately impacts female marketers whose earnings rely heavily on commissions linked to these often unrealistic goals. As a consequence, women face heightened vulnerability to harassment and abuse, contributing to severe burnout. Research especially shows that being female and under 35 are significant predictors of burnout in Nigeria’s banking sector. We must note here that what intensifies this pressure is the fact that over 75 per cent of employees in Nigerian financial institutions hold casual positions that lack benefits like maternity leave and job security. This model disproportionately affects women, who balance demanding careers with domestic responsibilities, often without adequate support at the home front. The result is high turnover and limited career progression, creating a workforce that is neither sustainable nor empowered. 

shop the republic

shop the republic

AGE AND CULTURAL MOUNTAINS: FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS AS A MIRROR OF THE SOCIETY

Ageist recruitment policies further compound the challenges women face. Many banks impose entry-level age limits as low as 24, effectively excluding women who start families early—a significant issue in a country where the average age at first pregnancy is 22. These restrictive policies penalize women for following established societal norms while simultaneously reducing the sector’s talent pool and reinforcing existing gender inequalities. Sterling Bank provides a telling example of this contradiction. Despite being recognized as a leader in gender diversity within the sector, as of 2022, the bank’s workforce was 45 per cent female. Sterling Bank is known for its inclusive initiatives, including flexible working hours for mothers that allow them to set convenient start and end times. The bank also offers a women-only development programme that features an online maternity hub to support pregnant employees, and a women-in-banking internship programme that aims to recruit young women exclusively. However, there is a notable caveat: like most banks in the sector, Sterling Bank has an age limit in its recruitment criteria—‘To be eligible for this opportunity, you must…not be older than 25 years at the time of application…’ This age restriction immediately undermines the inclusivity goals of such initiatives by limiting opportunities for women who may have delayed their careers due to family commitments.  

Beyond this structural barrier, cultural biases and micro-aggressions further impact women’s professional integrity. Female leaders face derogatory labels, cyberbullying and public scrutiny based on their appearance or marital status. We see, for instance, the accusations against a CBN director, Aisha Ahmad, for not covering her hair, and Zenith Bank CEO, Adaora Umeoji Nwokoye, who was dismissed as a ‘hook-up girl’ for her beauty. Such incidents highlight deep-rooted stereotypes that damage both individual reputations and the sector’s credibility.  

Ageism in the finance sector functions as a mirror reflecting societal expectations that define a woman’s value according to her stage in life. Younger women face assumptions that they lack the necessary skills for leadership positions, while older women confront pressure to prioritize family obligations or risk being dismissed as irrelevant in a rapidly evolving industry. On the one hand, marital status shapes women’s professional experiences through societal expectations about primary roles as caregivers and homemakers. Married women often struggle under the weight of the ‘double shift’ required to excel both at work and in their domestic responsibilities, which creates an uneven playing field in competition with male colleagues. Single women, on the other hand, often face suspicion or ostracization for defying traditional norms, further marginalizing them in professional spaces. These patterns reflect a broader societal pattern across Africa, where a woman’s identity and worth are tied to her domestic roles, limiting her ability to be seen as an independent professional. Outside the banking sector, cultural norms manifest through the preference for male candidates in leadership roles based on perceptions that men are more authoritative and decisive. These norms also manifest through the tolerance of discriminatory practices like sexual harassment or unequal pay. The banking sector thus serves as a microcosm of broader African societal dynamics that reinforce cultural norms prioritizing men as breadwinners and relegating women to supportive roles. Even when women break into the industry, these persistent cultural expectations can become an invisible ceiling that prevents them from fully asserting themselves or advancing their careers. 

shop the republic

shop the republic

EMBEDDING FEMINIST PRINCIPLES IN CORPORATE GOVERNANCE

Historically, corporate governance and accounting practices have fallen short in tackling gender equity issues as they often focus on surface-level compliance rather than meaningful change. Governance structures typically prioritize profit maximization and shareholder value, while neglecting their social responsibility to foster an inclusive environment. Similarly, accounting practices often use narrow metrics that obscure systemic problems, reducing diversity reporting to mere numbers without reflecting the real experiences of women in the sector. Yet, history offers valuable lessons here. African women have long played significant roles in finance and leadership, often through communal systems like cooperative savings groups and trade associations. These structures, which emphasize collaboration and mutual support, stand in stark contrast to the hierarchical and exclusionary practices of modern banking institutions. By revisiting these traditional models, we can develop alternative frameworks for addressing contemporary challenges. For example, integrating the principles of collective empowerment and accountability into modern financial systems could help dismantle the barriers that women face today. For Nigeria’s financial institutions, meaningful progress must go beyond superficial diversity metrics toward a feminist approach that actively confronts systemic inequalities. This means prioritizing social responsibility alongside profit, implementing genuinely inclusive policies and acknowledging women’s lived experiences, rather than relying on token representation. By fostering a culture that prioritizes inclusion and accountability, corporate leaders can transform these challenges into opportunities for sustainable growth, ensuring that progress for women in Nigeria’s financial sector is not only visible but also genuine and enduring

BUY THE MAGAZINE AND/OR THE COVER