The ‘Essence’ of Afrobeats

Afrobeats

Left to Right: Tyla, Davido, Tems and Burna Boy. Collage by THE REPUBLIC.

the ministry of arts / music dept.

The ‘Essence’ of Afrobeats

Afrobeats has gone global, but is Nigeria’s music industry winning or losing as a result of this success?
Afrobeats

Left to Right: Tyla, Davido, Tems and Burna Boy. Collage by THE REPUBLIC.

the ministry of arts / music dept.

The ‘Essence’ of Afrobeats

Afrobeats has gone global, but is Nigeria’s music industry winning or losing as a result of this success?

In February 2024, when Davido’s entourage stormed downtown Los Angeles and walked the red carpet into the Crypto Arena in February 2024, they were confident Davido would return to Lagos as a ‘Grammy Boy’. His hits ‘Unavailable’ and ‘Feel’ earned him two Grammy nominations, and his fourth album, Timeless, garnered a third. 2024 was a landmark year, and the nominations were seen as a reward for his long-standing service to Afrobeats. As they settled into their seats, his entourage seemed convinced that he would win at least one Grammy. 

However, Tyla’s summer anthem, ‘Water,’ posed a formidable challenge. The amapiano-sprinkled pop track transcended borders, casting a shadow over Davido’s shot at musical immortality. This was a contest where David needed more than a pebble to prevail. 

Months later, Davido’s loss—momentarily freezing the momentum of Afrobeats—has become a distant memory. The genre has resumed its upward trajectory, evidenced by the latest albums from Afrobeats’ leading women, Tems and Ayra Starr. 

Tems’ debut album, Born in the Wild, debuted at number five on the Billboard Top R&B Albums chart and at number 56 on the all-genre Billboard 200 chart, with 16,500 album units sold in its first week. Ayra Starr also wrote her name in the history books as the first Nigerian female artiste to debut on the Billboard 200 chart with her sophomore album, The Year I Turned 21. Making her entry at number 195, the album sold 8,000 album units in the United States of America in its first week. 

In a 2024 interview, Tems expressed that while Nigerians appreciate her music, they don’t fully understand her songs. Despite making her mark with tracks like ‘Try Me’ and ‘Mr Rebel’, it wasn’t until she went globally mainstream with ‘Wait For U’ that she started being taken more seriously in Nigeria. This interview arguably led to more people paying attention to her music. 

This context underscores why Davido’s loss to Tyla felt like a slap to some Nigerians, who exhibit a deep, protective love for their own artists. One Nigerian on X described Tyla’s ‘Water’ as ‘the most American passing sound in the category.’ To Davido’s entourage and many Nigerians, Davido was the more deserving winner. However, this raises some questions: How much refinement is needed for Nigeria’s hottest commodity to guarantee global mainstream success? Do budding talents need to reshape their musical identities to create a more marketable and resonant sonic persona for a worldwide audience? 

shop the republic

shop the republic

THE BACKSTORY

Before artists began denouncing Afrobeats and before Nigerian music was amalgamated under one name, much of what Nigerians digested as music was foreign imitation of what aired on MTV and Western television because of the sheer prominence of foreign music on Nigerian airwaves then. Loose-fitted jerseys, baggy pants—every aura and cadence of the Nigerian hip-hop scene echoed foreign influences. 

Fela Kuti didn’t start by making revolutionary music. Initially, he performed regular jazz, funk, and calypso, but it lacked the energy and political radicalism we now associate with the legend. It wasn’t until after 1960, when he returned from the US after a tour gone awry with his then-band, Koola Lobitos. However, despite being less than a fortuitous trip, Fela met artists, writers, and painters who made him realize how harnessing the knowledge of African history could aid the globalization of his music. Similarly, before becoming the legendary duo Junior and Pretty, in their audition for the show ‘Clapperboard Weekend Raps’ in 1991, both artists rapped with an American flavour despite being from Ajegunle. 

This is not to blame the historical lack of aesthetics in Nigerian music on anyone but to highlight the absence of a coherent structure. Because Nigerian music was not initially a packaged genre, its growth was hindered. 

In the early 2000s, after the era of the Lijadu sisters, as the dawn of Nigerian RnB and pop music broke, a sonic revolution began to take shape, marked by unique instrumentation and unmistakable flair. The enchanting melodies of Style Plus’s ‘Olufunmi’, the timeless romance of Seyi Sodimu’s ‘Love Me Jeje’ and the soulful serenade of Sunny Neji’s ‘Oruka’ showcased the burgeoning possibilities. 

Yet, a cultural conundrum lingered. Because it lacked a distinct identity, popular Nigerian music often fused styles from other genres, striving to captivate global ears. Everything changed in 2012, when D’banj’s ‘Oliver Twist’ shattered the proverbial glass ceiling, solidifying the essence of Nigerian music through the vibrant, unstoppable force of Afrobeats. 

shop the republic

shop the republic

THE IDENTITY OF AFROBEATS

How often have you rolled your eyes at the tired ‘Nigerian Prince’ stereotype and thought, ‘That’s not all there is to Nigeria.’ That outdated identity once defined every Nigerian. Now, consider this: when was the last time you heard an Afrobeats song in a British or American film instead of that old trope? Not too long ago, right? 

Afrobeats has found a second home in the UK, much like many Nigerians who have relocated there. This genre, deeply rooted in Nigerian culture, and fresh in a new country has to start making returns for its relatives: the food, fashion and other parts of the culture that hold it together. 

I spoke to Zaddy Of Lagos, a media executive and the manager of Grammy-nominated Bloody Civilian, who views Afrobeats as a cultural phenomenon. ‘I see Afrobeats differently,’ he said. ‘It’s about the sound, energy, culture, cuisine, fashion, and the never-say-die mentality.’ 

Zaddy disagrees that the Afrobeats genre is a Western attempt to box in African sound, arguing it’s an honest classification effort. ‘They heard R&B from an unexpected place and classified it to understand it,’ he explained. This simplistic classification approach overlooks Afrobeats’ rich ethos and multicoloured palette, something the Grammys are beginning to appreciate. 

A deeper understanding could have averted the ‘biting the hand that fed you’ debacle of the past eight months, where artists like Grammy winner Burna Boy, long-time Afrobeats icon Wizkid, and Afro-pop virtuoso Fireboy denounced the genre, muddying the waters they once drank from at the sound of thunder. Denying Afrobeats now is like denying one’s culture, especially when it’s cool to be Nigerian—such poor timing. 

Zaddy concludes by saying the chest-pumping arose because ‘they looked at Afrobeats as a genre. Nobody wants to be in a genre box.’ He attributes Nigerians’ obsession with Western approval to neocolonialism. He said: 

We need to get out of the mindset that we need to play to the westerners. A lot of this mindset comes from neocolonialism; the immediate doing, arguing about what Afrobeats is, even deciding that before you do music, you need to think of the genre. Nobody thinks of the genre when they’re enjoying it. 

However, could overexposure to cultural elements become detrimental to Afrobeats? Might artists need to shed the ‘nothingness’ of Afrobeats and embrace ‘substance’? With the fame and attention current Afrobeats stars are getting, could classification be a problem? 

shop the republic

shop the republic

ESSENCE THIS, ESSENCE THAT

One of the benefits of Afrobeats’ popularity is the diversification of its fandom. In the past, a small circle of musicians like Tuface (now 2Baba), D’banj, and P Square dominated the scene. Now, both established stars and emerging artists enjoy a broad and dedicated fanbase. 

Additionally, allegedly, when Nigerian artists crossed over internationally, it marked a turning point in their sound. An example that explains this is Wizkid with his third album Sounds From The Other Side (2017). That same year, he signed with the label, RCA Records. The same with Davido and tracks like ‘If’ and ‘Fall’ and Burna Boy with ‘Outside’ who released these projects after they signed to international labels. 

The upside about what’s happening with the ‘new cats’, such as Rema, Tems, Ayra Starr, is they’re the next generation and they came with a shorter distance to ‘blow’ ratio. Their uniqueness shone so loudly that by their debut albums, they’re heading out on world tours, credits to Tems and Victony. 

The diversification of fandom and the accelerated rise of artists have collectively created a promising structure for new talent. This evolution has given rise to distinct sub-genres within Afrobeats, creating several channels to success compared to the past reliance on reality shows like Project Fame, The Voice, and Nigerian Idol to produce talent. However, this multiple-routefame has also made it challenging for Afrobeats to produce new talent, resulting in a growing chasm between current hitmakers and their successors. 

Recognizing this potential, international labels are investing in Nigerian record companies with a proven track record of nurturing and developing artists, preparing them for global stardom. Notable examples include Warner Music’s partnership with Chocolate City, Universal’s multimillion-dollar deal with Mavin, and Def Jam Recordings’ collaboration with Native Records. 

Nigerian music executive Obi Asika dismisses the notion that Afrobeats artists must alter their essence to appeal to global audiences and labels. He told me how international labels have learned from their past mistakes in trying to adapt Afrobeats for their markets. He said: 

I don’t know a single successful Nigerian artist who changed their sound to adapt to anybody. Eazi didn’t change his sound in 2019, Burna Boy hasn’t, Wizkid hasn’t, and the same goes for Davido. 

In the past, sure, that’s what major labels did—trying to adjust artists for releases in their market if they thought it would help them sell. But in the first three or four years, Afrobeats artists were neither selling nor streaming in big numbers. This was exemplified by Davido and his album Son of Mercy, which was a cultural and commercial flop. For the past three years, they’ve realized that to enjoy the Nigerian experience, it needs to be authentic, and the Mavin deal is a testament to that. 

So, if those international music companies we looked to for entertainment back in the day are moving here to get our sound unadulterated and in mint condition, what really is the essence? Afrobeats has infiltrated American pop culture and perhaps world pop culture for life. Our culture as Nigerians, which includes Afrobeats, has left our shores and settled in the beautiful beaches around the world. 

So maybe Davido should have won the Grammy, considering all he’s done for the genre. Perhaps Wizkid, Fireboy, and Burna Boy were right to deny Afrobeats, considering how overpopulated the genre is these days. Perhaps Portable is the future?  

Could it be fear? The fear that we’d burn out as quickly as we’ve come. Was the tantrum of losing the Grammys coming from the fear of being forgotten? Is that why everyone is jumping the Afrobeats ship so as to not go down with the rest of the crew?  

While everything else is ifs and maybes, the fact that we obsess over global recognition and gratification happens to be a tumour in Afrobeats. Zaddy says he’s never been a fan of international gratification. ‘As Nigerians, we depend so much on international recognition, which is a good thing. Winning a Grammy is nice and all, but if you can’t win a Grammy,’ he said, ‘the success should be how many people you’re able to touch.’ 

Asika echoed something similar. He said, ‘The real win for Afrobeats wasn’t the nomination but Burna Boy’s performance that night.’ That night, Burna Boy became the first ever Nigerian to perform at the Grammys. But we’re so engrossed in winning or losing Grammys that we lost sight of what was important: the continued growth of Afrobeats. It’s still too soon to say if the tumour is benign or terminal, but hopefully, it’s nothing to worry about

shop the republic

BUY THE MAGAZINE AND/OR THE COVER

BUY THE MAGAZINE AND/OR THE COVER